| 1. | William Hartsell | 5-1924 | * |
| 2. | Dave Rutan | 3-1969 | |
| 3. | Dennis Madigan | 7-2-1969 | |
| 4. | Tony Accardo | 2-1970 | |
| 5. | John Accardo | 4-1970 | |
| 6. | Steve Lienhart | 4-1970 | |
| 7. | Joe Duncan | 9-1971 | |
| 8. | Greg Dyekman | 9-1971 | |
| 9. | Tim Miller | 5-1973 | |
| 10. | Tom Mason | 11-1973 | |
| 11. | Mike King | 1-1974 | |
| 12. | Russ Rutan | 1-1974 | |
| 13. | Paul Devine | 9-1975 | |
| 14. | Tom Accardo | 11-1975 | |
| 15. | Bart Accardo | 11-1975 | |
| 16. | Phil Brimmer | 1-1976 | |
| 17. | Eugene Smith | 10-18-1976 | |
| 18. | Scott Steere | 12-13-1976 | |
| 19. | Kevin Amen | 8-31-1977 | |
| 20. | Kyle Amen | 8-31-1977 | |
| 21. | Kevin Madigan | 12-9-1977 | |
| 22. | Rob Rutan | 12-14-1977 | |
| 23. | Todd Dray | 11-7-1978 | |
| 24. | Brooks Hinkle | 11-7-1978 | |
| 25. | Bill Willingham | 1-15-1979 | |
| 26. | Kendall Adams | 1-19-1981 | |
| 27. | Daniel Noblitt | 4-20-1981 | |
| 28. | Steven Rice | 7-13-1981 | |
| 29. | Ricky Willingham | 1-14-1982 | |
| 30. | Jim Travis | 2-15-1982 | |
| 31. | Scott Foresman | 6-1-1982 | |
| 32. | Mike Sullivan | 6-8-1982 | |
| 33. | Curt Hinkle | 8-30-1982 | |
| 34. | Andy Austin | 10-22-1982 | |
| 35. | Raymond Brand | 10-22-1982 | |
| 36. | Vincent Meyer | 11-22-1982 | |
| 37. | Donald Dickman | 12-10-1982 | |
| 38. | Bill Smith | 12-16-1982 | |
| 39. | Bobby Kanard | 10-13-1983 | |
| 40. | Greg Guthridge | 11-7-1983 | |
| 41. | Doug Noblitt | 3-13-1984 | |
| 42. | Bobby Austin | 4-23-1984 | |
| 43. | Rob Bourg | 5-17-1984 | |
| 44. | John Macke | 10-11-1984 | |
| 45. | David Toft | 11-19-1984 | |
| 46. | Jack Meena | 12-21-1984 | |
| 47. | John Sullivan | 12-26-1984 | |
| 48. | Kevin Rice | 1-29-1985 | |
| 49. | Danton Tibbetts | 1-29-1985 | |
| 50. | Mike Atwell | 8-26-1985 | |
| 51. | Richard Brand | 2-25-1986 | |
| 52. | Scott Pendleton | 8-7-1986 | |
| 53. | Tim Atwell | 8-26-1986 | |
| 54. | Edward Leber | 7-10-1987 | |
| 55. | Tim Sullivan | 11-21-1987 | |
| 56. | Chad Buggert | 7-26-1988 | |
| 57. | Tim Macke | 8-21-1989 | |
| 58. | Michael Randall | 4-29-1991 | |
| 59. | Marshall Davis | 1-22-1992 | |
| 60. | William Palmer | 4-15-1993 | |
| 61. | Sean Stoughton | 10-28-1994 | |
| 62. | James Waller | 4-18-1996 | |
| 63. | Morgan Neelands | 3-30-1999 | |
| 64. | Andrew Eickbush | 5-6-1999 | |
| 65. | Travis Thompson | 10-14-1999 | |
| 66. | Jacob Rinker | 4-14-2000 | |
| 67. | Dain Bassett | 2-26-2001 | |
| 68. | Tracy Thompson | 2-27-2001 | |
| 69. | Cody Sunderman | 8-30-2001 | |
| 70. | Tim Read | 12-30-2002 | |
| 71. | Zach Rinker | 1-3-2003 | |
| 72. | Alan Eickbush | 1-18-2003 | |
| 73. | Mick Farrell | 3-31-2003 | |
| 74. | Ethan Eshelman | 8-24-2004 | |
| 75. | Josh Hudson | 10-22-2004 | |
| 76. | Mark Mazza II | 12-15-2004 | |
| 77. | Cody Pate | 12-15-2004 | |
| 78. | Jeff Parkins | 12-15-2004 | |
| 79. | Leland Duck | 2-21-2005 | |
| 80. | Zack Lemaster | 3-16-2005 | |
| 81. | Alex Huff | 8-25-2005 | |
| 82. | Roman Fresquez | 11-28-2005 | |
| 83. | Jonathan Hedger | 1-19-2006 | |
| 84. | Garrett Keyes | 4-5-2006 | |
| 85. | Tyler Keyes | 9-27-2007 | |
| 86. | Dillion Johnson | 9-27-2007 | |
| 87. | Charles Torrance | 4-24-2008 | |
| 88. | Ruben Fugate | 8-28-2008 | |
| 89. | Christopher Bliss | 11-20-2008 | |
| 90. | Conroy Stout | 1-22-2009 | |
| 91. | Kyle Nieft | 3-25-2010 | |
| 92. | Allen Hebert | 6-24-2010 | |
| 93. | James Segrave | 10-28-2010 | |
| 94. | Adam Wales | 2-24-2011 | |
| 95. | Coulter Calvetti | 7-28-2011 | |
| 96. | Austin Segrave | 11-17-2011 | |
| 97. | Jason Wales | 1-26-2012 |
* Cheyenne's First Eagle Scout